Dropshipping vs Print-on-Demand on Shopify (2024)

What Are These Two Business Models?

If you're thinking about starting an online store with Shopify, you've probably come across two very popular options: dropshipping and print-on-demand (POD). Both allow you to sell products without holding any inventory, which makes them incredibly attractive for beginners with limited budgets. But they work in very different ways, and choosing the right one can make or break your early success.

Before diving into comparisons, let's quickly define each model so you're working with a clear picture.

How Dropshipping Works

With dropshipping, you list products from third-party suppliers in your Shopify store. When a customer places an order, the supplier ships the product directly to them. You never touch the inventory. Popular platforms like AliExpress, Spocket, or DSers connect you with thousands of suppliers across countless product categories — from electronics to home décor.

How Print-on-Demand Works

Print-on-demand follows a similar fulfillment process, but with a creative twist. You design custom graphics that get printed on products like t-shirts, mugs, phone cases, and hoodies. When someone buys, the POD provider (such as Printful or Printify) prints and ships the item. No warehouse, no bulk orders, no waste.

Startup Costs and Initial Investment

One of the first questions beginners ask is: how much do I need to get started? The good news is that both models are low-cost compared to traditional retail. However, there are some differences worth noting.

• Dropshipping: Your main costs are your Shopify subscription, a domain name, and potentially a dropshipping app. Some suppliers may charge membership fees. You can realistically start for under $50/month.
• Print-on-demand: Startup costs are similarly low. Most POD platforms are free to join. You'll pay per order only when a sale is made. Design tools like Canva can be used for free, keeping costs minimal.

Both models let you start lean, but print-on-demand has a slight edge for true zero-inventory beginners since there are no surprise supplier fees or minimum order requirements to worry about.

Profit Margins: Where Does the Money Go?

Understanding your margins is critical before you commit to a model. This is where the two paths start to diverge more noticeably.

With dropshipping, margins can range widely — anywhere from 10% to 40% depending on the niche and supplier. Products sourced from overseas suppliers (especially from China) tend to be cheaper, allowing for higher markups. However, shipping times can be long, and competition on popular products is fierce.

Print-on-demand margins are generally more predictable but can be tighter. A t-shirt might cost you $12–$15 to produce and you could sell it for $25–$35, leaving a margin of around 30–50%. The advantage is that your product is unique — branded with your designs — which gives you more pricing power and reduces direct competition.

Which Model Is Easier to Scale?

Scaling is where things get interesting. Both models can grow significantly, but they require different strategies.

Scaling a Dropshipping Store

Dropshipping scales well when you find winning products quickly. Many dropshippers use paid ads (especially Facebook or TikTok ads) to test multiple products fast. The challenge is that once a product goes viral, competitors can copy your store almost overnight. You'll need to keep finding new winning products to stay ahead.

Scaling a Print-on-Demand Store

POD stores scale through brand building and organic traffic. Because your designs are original, you build a recognizable brand over time. Many successful POD sellers grow through Instagram, Pinterest, or Etsy alongside their Shopify store. Scaling is slower initially but tends to be more sustainable long-term.

Time Commitment and Learning Curve

For complete beginners, the learning curve matters. Here's an honest breakdown:

• Dropshipping requires research into product trends, supplier vetting, and often significant ad spend to test products. It can feel overwhelming at first, especially when ads don't convert immediately.
• Print-on-demand requires creative skills or the willingness to learn basic design. However, the operational side is simpler — fewer supplier relationships to manage and more consistent product quality.

If you enjoy creativity and want to build a brand, POD will feel more natural. If you prefer data-driven product hunting and faster potential wins, dropshipping might suit your style better.

So, Which One Should Beginners Choose?

There's no single right answer — it depends on your goals, skills, and how much time you can invest. That said, here's a simple guide:

• Choose print-on-demand if you're creative, want to build a brand, and prefer steady, sustainable growth with minimal risk.
• Choose dropshipping if you're comfortable with marketing, willing to test products quickly, and want faster potential revenue — even if it comes with more competition.

Many successful entrepreneurs actually start with one model and later combine both. The most important step is simply getting started, learning from real experience, and adjusting as you go.

← See all articles